Category: Peer Review

Questions about reviewer selection, evaluation of reviews, and the role of peer review in editorial decision-making.

How should an editor recruit reviewers?

Diane B. Monsivais discusses the essential role of peer reviewers in maintaining journal quality. Effective editors cultivate reviewer communities through targeted outreach, mentoring, and relationship management. Strategies include personalized engagement, author recruitment, and recognizing reviewers' contributions. Sustaining these relationships fosters integrity and quality in scholarly publishing.
DOI:  https://doi.org/10.67130/wges.2026.010 . . .

This content is part of the Working Guide to Editorial Systems.

Access is available to subscribers.

Join us for practical guidance, real editorial decisions,

and to learn more about the systems that shape scholarly publishing.

Join Now to Continue Reading

Already a subscriber? Log in here

What qualifications do peer reviewers need to have?

Linda Laskowski-Jones discusses the importance of selecting peer reviewers based not solely on academic credentials but on relevant expertise tailored to the type of manuscript. This flexible approach enhances review quality and promotes the inclusion of diverse perspectives, ultimately supporting the development of future reviewers in scholarly publishing.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.67130/wges.2026.006 . . .

This content is part of the Working Guide to Editorial Systems.

Access is available to subscribers.

Join us for practical guidance, real editorial decisions,

and to learn more about the systems that shape scholarly publishing.

Join Now to Continue Reading

Already a subscriber? Log in here